ReviewHome & Garden
Great Jones Cookware Review: Colorful Cookware With Real Winners — Buy the Dutch Oven and Sheet Pan, Skip the Nonstick
Great Jones' Dutchess Dutch oven and Holy Sheet pan are genuinely excellent for the money — but nonstick pans that lose performance quickly, occasional coating chips and warping, and a lid handle that's awkward with oven mitts mean you should choose pieces carefully.
rating 7.5 / 10
7.5/10
- Best for
- Home cooks who want beautiful, colorful Dutch ovens and bakeware at a fraction of heritage-brand prices
- Price
- Around $30 (sheet pans on sale) – $205 (The Dutchess full price)greatjonesgoods.com
The shortlist
04 PRODUCTS · PRICES CHECKED AUTOMATICALLY
-
Best Overall Pick The Dutchess (6.75 qt) — ~$160–$205, often ~$110–$125 on sale $205 Great Jones
-
Best Value Pick Holy Sheet Pan — ~$45, often ~$30 on sale $45 Great Jones
-
Premium / Upgrade Pick King Sear (12" Cast Iron) — ~$110, often ~$65 on sale $125 Great Jones
-
Approach With Caution Nonstick Fry Pans (Small Fry / Large Fry) $90
$105Great Jones
How this works — Links to shops may earn FailleGlam a commission. It never decides what we recommend, the score, or the order. Prices are read from each shop and shown with the time we last checked. How we review →
01 Why We Reviewed Great Jones
Great Jones launched in New York to make stylish, well-built cookware more affordable, and its colorful pieces quickly became Instagram favorites. The standout is The Dutchess, a 6.75-quart enameled cast-iron oval Dutch oven that's oven-safe to 500°F and works on all stovetops, including induction. It's backed by a limited lifetime warranty and costs far less than a comparable Le Creuset — one comparison noted Le Creuset's same-size pot runs $445 and up. The Holy Sheet pan has earned its own fan club: The Kitchn's editors named it a favorite, saying nothing stuck and cleanup was a breeze.
The honest caveat: not every Great Jones product is a winner. Thingtesting's review summary flags chipping ceramic coating on some sheet pans, nonstick longevity that disappoints quickly, occasional warping under high heat, and uneven heating on oversized cast iron. One buyer called their Small Fry pan "truly awful" after it turned sticky with minimal use. Critics also note The Dutchess lid handle is small and hard to grip with mitts, and that budget brands like Lodge offer Dutch ovens for much less.
02 Great Jones at a Glance
At a glance
- Founded
- 2018 — New York, NY
- Product Category
- Cookware, bakeware, cast iron, stainless steel and kitchen tools
- Price Range
- ~$30 (sheet pans on sale) – $160–$205 (The Dutchess) – $600+ (sets)
- Ships To
- USA — free standard shipping over a set order value
- Made In
- China (per product details for The Dutchess)
- Warranty
- Limited lifetime warranty on select items like The Dutchess
- Return Policy
- Returns on unused items within the stated window — check current terms
- Available At
- greatjonesgoods.com, select retailers
- Review Count
- Hundreds of on-site reviews per hero product; strong editorial coverage
- FailleGlam Rating
- 7.5 / 10
03 What FailleGlam Found: The Honest Breakdown
-
+01
✅ The Dutchess is excellent value A 6.75-quart enameled cast-iron Dutch oven that retains heat well and costs a fraction of Le Creuset.
-
+02
✅ Versatile oval shape Fits a whole chicken or a loaf of bread, and doubles as a roasting pan.
-
+03
✅ Holy Sheet is an editor favorite The Kitchn praised its nonstick release and easy cleanup; long-term owners say it still looks new after months.
-
+04
✅ Durable color finishes Reviewers report bright colors that hold up even in the dishwasher on sheet pans.
-
+05
✅ Frequent, meaningful sales The Dutchess regularly drops to around $110–$125 and the Holy Sheet to about $30.
-
−01
❌ Nonstick pans lose performance fast Reviews highlight nonstick longevity as a recurring disappointment.
-
−02
❌ Occasional chipping and warping Some owners report chipped coating on sheet pans and warping under high heat.
-
−03
❌ Awkward Dutchess lid handle The small metal knob is hard to grip with a mitt on a heavy lid.
-
−04
❌ Budget brands cost less Lodge and Tramontina Dutch ovens cost much less if design isn't your priority.
Our readGreat Jones is strongest in enameled cast iron and bakeware. Build your kitchen around those, and look elsewhere for nonstick.
04 Best Great Jones Products Worth Considering
Great Jones sells everything from Dutch ovens to stainless sets. After reviewing editorial tests and buyer feedback, here are the standouts — and one to approach carefully.
Great Jones
The Dutchess (6.75 qt) — ~$160–$205, often ~$110–$125 on sale
The Dutchess is Great Jones' signature: enameled cast iron that holds heat beautifully for braises, stews and bread, moves from stove to oven to table, and cleans up easily. Its oval shape gives extra room for browning and roasting. Buy it on sale and use a mitt that fits well around the small lid knob.
Great Jones
Holy Sheet Pan — ~$45, often ~$30 on sale
At 18.5 by 13.5 inches, this aluminized steel sheet pan is large, dishwasher-safe and oven-safe to 450°F. The Kitchn's editors ranked it among their favorites, and owners say it still looks great after regular use. Hand-washing will help protect the coating long-term. If you're comparing sheet pans, see our Caraway bakeware review for a side-by-side.
Great Jones
King Sear (12" Cast Iron) — ~$110, often ~$65 on sale
A pre-seasoned 12-inch cast iron skillet that reviewers praise for easy food release and cleanup. Great for searing and baking. Some buyers note very large cast iron can heat unevenly on smaller burners, so preheat gradually.
Great Jones
Nonstick Fry Pans (Small Fry / Large Fry)
Nonstick is Great Jones' weakest category. One buyer who used a Small Fry only for eggs and toasting said it turned sticky after minimal use. If you want nonstick, consider dedicated nonstick or ceramic brands instead.
05 What Buyers Are Actually Saying
A verified buyer describes finding The Dutchess:
I wanted a great Dutch oven without spending $400–$500. The Dutchess works beautifully and cleans up so easily — it's a work of art.
A Holy Sheet owner shares their experience:
Six months in with two Holy Sheets — they're super easy to clean, have no stubborn buildup, and still look brand new.
On the concerns side, a buyer describes nonstick disappointment:
The Dutch oven gets the job done, but the frying pan got sticky after minimal use — and I take very careful care of my cookware.
Another reviewer critiques The Dutchess design:
The lid handle is simply too small, and with a heavy lid you need a glove — getting a grip is difficult.
The pattern: The Dutchess and Holy Sheet earn consistent praise, while nonstick durability and small design details draw the complaints.
06 Great Jones vs The Competition
| Great Jones vs The Competition | Our pick Great Jones Dutchess | Le Creuset | Lodge Enameled |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price Range | ~$110–$205 | $445+ | ~$60–$100 |
| Quality / Build | ✅ Enameled cast iron | ✅ Premium French cast iron | ✅ Solid basics |
| Warranty | Limited lifetime | Lifetime | Limited |
| Oven Safe | 500°F | Up to ~500°F | ~500°F |
| Shape | Oval | Round and oval | Mostly round |
| Design | ✅ Bold modern colors | ✅ Iconic colors | ⚠️ Basic |
| Unique Strength | Style at mid-range price | Heritage quality | Lowest price |
| Best For | Style-conscious cooks | Lifetime heirloom buyers | Budget buyers |
For a deeper breakdown, see our full Le Creuset review.
07 Is Great Jones Right For You?
Perfect For
Home cooks who want a beautiful, reliable Dutch oven and bakeware without paying heritage-brand prices — and who enjoy cookware that doubles as table decor.
Worth Considering If
You're building a full kitchen from scratch. Start with The Dutchess and Holy Sheet, then fill in other pieces from brands that specialize in nonstick or stainless.
Skip It If
You mainly need nonstick fry pans or want the cheapest Dutch oven possible. Specialized nonstick brands or Lodge will serve you better.
08 FailleGlam Recommends
Great Jones
The Dutchess (6.75 qt) — ~$110–$125 on sale
It's the best-reviewed piece Great Jones makes: heat-retaining, versatile and beautiful, with a limited lifetime warranty. Wait for a sale — it drops significantly several times a year — and pick a color you'll love leaving on the stove.
09 Great Jones — Questions We Get Asked Most
Q.01Great Jones Dutchess vs Le Creuset — which should I buy?
The Dutchess for great performance and style at a much lower price. Le Creuset if you want a lifetime heirloom and don't mind paying several times more.
Q.02Is Great Jones cookware oven safe?
Yes. The Dutchess is oven-safe to 500°F and the Holy Sheet to 450°F. Check each product's limits.
Q.03Is the Great Jones Holy Sheet worth it?
Yes, especially on sale. It's large, easy to clean and an editor favorite at The Kitchn.
Q.04Are Great Jones nonstick pans durable?
They're the brand's weakest category, with reports of sticking after limited use. Consider other nonstick brands.
Q.05Where is Great Jones cookware made?
Product details for The Dutchess list China as the country of manufacture.